Released: February 25, 2011
Purchased: Early 2012 I think, from Amazon.
First Thoughts: This isn't exactly filled with the pop bops I normally go for, so that tells you how excellent it is, that it's my second-favorite album in the world. I guess the closest comparison I can make is Florence, but less rock and more generally subdued. Her voice is just wonderful. I'm looking forward to this.
Playthrough:
Are You Ready? - Pointless like 90% of album intros.
Shield and Sword - This was what got me into Clare. It is a monster of a song - very Kate Bush in some ways, but with that Cher/Moyet-ish voice. I remember totally connecting it to The Hunger Games, which I was reading at the time. It really isn't a great metaphor, but I don't care because this is an amazing song.
Last Dance - One of the more "pop" moments on here. It's not intended to be romantic - it was inspired by the deaths of Clare's grandpa and Michael Jackson - but it's definitely easy to read it as a "friends to lovers" song, and you know I'll never say no to that. The orchestral backing track is a huge plus too.
Freedom - Not one of my favorites. I don't remember if this or Bullet is the one on the album she didn't co-write, but I think it's this one, and it does kind of stick out. It's just not as developed as the rest.
I Surrender - Definitely the most "pop" song on the album. It's very bright and shiny - think Taylor Swift's Treacherous or State of Grace crossed with Tegan and Sara's Heartthrob album. Even though it's not as blissful in its production as I always remember it being, it still comes across as euphoric, though that may be because of the contrast with the rest of the album!
Bullet - This is another very Kate Bush-like song, but it sounds so much better than most of Kate's songs thanks to Clare's endlessly pleasant voice and the modern production. "You shot that bullet through myyyy heaaaaaaaaaarrrrrt" is definitely the album's best display of Clare's vocal abilities.
The Happiest Pretenders - I remember her saying she wrote this to be a song that children could dance to on the playground or something, which is frankly bizarre, because I cannot imagine children really engaging with this song (or indeed most of the album). But it's a lovely song about the gap between fantasy and reality, always one of my favorite topics for a song.
Sweet Lie - I always kind of remember this as being better than it is, probably because the chorus is so much more compelling than the verses. Listening to it now, it actually comes across as kind of fillery, but still truer to the album than Freedom.
Break These Chains - Also quite fillery actually, though I know at times when I've played the album I've loved it. Guess I'm just not in the mood.
You're Electric - This isn't even one of my favorites on the album, but from the instant that intro kicks in, it always grabs me, and doesn't let go until it's over. I totally understand why it was the first single. The auto-tune at the end is so tasteful and a great example of how to use it to enhance a song to great effect. Everything about this song is so BIG.
Ain't Nobody - One of the least special songs on the album, and you can definitely tell it was from earlier on while she was still figuring out her sound. But it's still a very good listen. The chorus is great, as is "you were my desire, yeah, you were my escape."
Light After Dark - I need this to be used as the ending song of a movie, with the screen going black and the credits rolling just as the second verse starts. It's so dramatic, and the lyrics are wonderful and comforting.
This Is Not the End - Feels very much like the album closer. Really lovely and seems like a companion piece to Last Dance.
Final verdict: I'm actually confused right now because this really didn't do it for me tonight like I'd expect my second-favorite album to do. Right now I'd probably give it a 7, but when I've listened to it before it's been a solid 10. Maybe it's just an off night. Too bad they didn't include Lucky (free fan club download), though - that's another amazing song that would have fit in really well.
Highlight: Close call with Shield and Sword, but I think Last Dance is the one I come back to more often. Beautiful video too.